Brian Marsella, president of HPS/PayMedix, recently joined a Milwaukee Business Journal Table of Experts on employer health plan costs, alongside Michael Schiewer of Hausmann Group and Justin Jasniewski of Serve You Rx. The panel was moderated by Beth Kerstein of MRA – The Management Association.
Health care costs are becoming unsustainable for many employers. A variety of market forces are driving up expenses as the economy struggles. Shifting more of the health care cost burden to employees is increasingly unsustainable. Employers are seeking dramatic changes to their health care benefits, and some are considering dropping them altogether.
What is driving costs
- Specialty drugs, especially GLP-1s and high-cost biologics, are a major driver of prescription spending.
- More treatments are covered, including mental health, and new therapies keep arriving.
- Government payment gaps push costs onto commercial plans as Medicare and Medicaid pay providers less than the cost of care.
- Pharmacy rebates often don’t reach employees, and smaller employers may not see them at all.
Top takeaways from the Table of Experts Panel:
GLP-1s: a cost driver and a recruiting tool
GLP-1s cut both ways. Justin Jasniewski noted that roughly three in ten employees said in one survey they would change jobs to get coverage, yet four in ten adult plan members could be eligible, at a sticker price above $1,000 a month. He also cautioned that medical savings take years to appear, so high turnover means funding someone else’s results.
The panel agreed that coverage alone isn’t enough. Michael Schiewer outlined several ways to cover GLP-1s, including through the health plan, an HRA reimbursement model, voluntary coverage, or access paired with member support. He added that members want dietitians and specialists who hold them accountable, not just virtual coaches. Brian Marsella made the financial case: if members quit after three or four months, the money is wasted, and the cost-share has to be workable for individuals.
Pharmacy costs: know who runs your benefit
Rebates are central to the pricing gap. They typically flow from manufacturers to PBMs to employers and rarely reach employees. Schiewer pointed out that employers with fewer than 100 people on the plan are probably paying full price while their carrier keeps the rebates.
Jasniewski’s advice is to look closely at your PBM: Is it independent or carrier-owned? Is it transparent? How is it paid? Help is coming on the regulatory side. The Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026 requires PBMs to pass 100 percent of rebates through to employer plans and disclose how they are paid, effective for most employers in 2029. Schiewer also reminded employers that fiduciary responsibility applies to level-funded plans just as it does to self-funded ones.
Care, and affordability, at the point of service
Marsella emphasized getting people into primary care early so chronic conditions don’t become expensive hospital stays. In HPS’s book of business, member use of physician and non-hospital care is 14 percent higher than the market average, while hospital use is 14 percent lower. Schiewer agreed that direct primary care belongs in any plan, with longer visits and referrals to lower-cost sites for imaging and surgery.
Affordability is the other half. A family health plan can now cost $28,000, and employee costs are rising about three times faster than inflation. Some hospitals even require payment up front before scheduling care, which can push people toward the emergency room. Marsella’s advice: help members make good care decisions, then give them a financial backstop so they can afford the care they need.
Read the full panel discussion here.